Jewish Advocacy Playbook
Actionable strategies for creating positive change on your campus created by students, for Jewish students and community members.
Dear Jewish college student or community member,
You hold in your hands a playbook born from real-world experience in campus advocacy. As a recent graduate of the University of Wisconsin-Madison, I led the Renew the Wisconsin Idea campaign, a student-driven initiative that successfully addressed campus antisemitism and promoted a more inclusive university environment. This guide distills our strategies, tactics, and hard-won lessons into a comprehensive resource designed specifically for you. It is my hope that these insights will empower you to effectively advocate for positive change on your own campus, ensuring that all students can thrive in a safe and respectful academic environment.
If you have any questions, feel free to send me an email.
Ben Newman
Table of contents
  • Using this Playbook to Make Change
Using this Playbook to Make Change
This playbook is designed to empower Jewish activists on university campuses with the tools, strategies, and knowledge needed to effectively advocate for their rights and address issues of antisemitism on campus. Drawing from successful campaigns like Renew the Wisconsin Idea, this guide provides a comprehensive framework for organizing, communicating, and driving change within your university community as well as a set of AI tools to help you on every part of your journey.
The written playbook and AI tools combine to create a comprehensive influence kit:
The Playbook
A step-by-step guide to creating and maintaining a successful influence campaign
The Tools
AI tools for executing steps in the playbook, allowing you to run a campaign regardless of experience
Key Learnings from Our Efforts
As we learned from the Renew the Wisconsin Idea campaign, organized and strategic advocacy can lead to significant achievements, even in challenging circumstances. By adopting a structured approach, you can:
  1. Effectively counter extreme demands and provide a reasoned voice in campus discussions.
  1. Maintain sustained engagement with university administration.
  1. Address immediate concerns while laying groundwork for long-term improvements in campus climate and policy.
  1. Raise awareness about antisemitism and the challenges faced by Jewish students.
  1. Influence university policy and decision-making processes.
The Renew the Wisconsin Idea campaign demonstrated that student advocates can effectively influence university policy and public discourse when armed with thorough research, strategic communication, and a commitment to upholding foundational principles of academic freedom and civil discourse.
This playbook will guide you through the process of building an effective advocacy campaign, from forming your team and crafting your message to engaging with administration and leveraging technology. By following these strategies, you'll be well-equipped to navigate complex issues while striving for a more inclusive and respectful campus environment.
Leverage AI for Campus Advocacy
Maccabee.ai lowers the barriers to effective advocacy with a suite of AI tools. Here's how to leverage these game-changing resources:
1
Onboarding
Interview with our Context Statement Generator and save the output. This helps AI learn more about you.
2
Find Your Tool in the Playbook
Find the tool that is best suited for your needs within the playbook and paste in the context statement when asked.
3
Copy and Edit the Output
When you are happy with the results, copy the output and edit it on your own before usage.
1. Onboarding: Start with the Context Statement Generator
Think of this as your AI orientation interview. This tool will ask you key questions about your advocacy goals, campus environment, and current challenges. The resulting context statement is your personalized advocacy profile – a concise summary of your unique situation.
Pro Tip: Save this context statement in a note or document. You'll use it repeatedly to quickly brief other AI tools, saving you valuable time and ensuring consistency across your campaign.
2. Using AI: Choose Your AI Tool and Begin the Conversation
Maccabee.ai offers a variety of specialized AI assistants, each designed to help with specific aspects of your advocacy journey. Whether you need help crafting policy requests, preparing for media interviews, or writing compelling reports, there's a tool tailored for your needs.
When you start a conversation with your chosen AI tool, it will ask for context. This is where your saved context statement comes in handy. Simply paste it in, and the AI will immediately understand your situation, allowing you to dive right into your specific task.
Remember: These AI tools are here to enhance your efforts, not replace your unique insights and experiences. Use them to brainstorm ideas, refine your messaging, and streamline your workflow – but always apply your own judgment and understanding of your campus's nuances.
By integrating these AI tools into your advocacy strategy, you're not just keeping up with technology – you're staying steps ahead of potential challenges. Maccabee.ai empowers you to punch above your weight, compete with better-resourced opposition, and make a lasting impact on your campus.
Ready to get started? Let's dive into the world of AI-enhanced advocacy and transform your campus for the better!
Anatomy of a Campaign
Example Timeline of Advocacy
No two advocacy campaigns are identical - the causes vary, circumstances differ, and the people involved bring unique perspectives and skills. The timeline that follows is based on the successful strategies employed during the Renew the Wisconsin Idea campaign. It's designed to serve as a flexible framework, not a rigid script.
As you review this timeline, remember its key lesson: effective advocacy often requires simultaneous action on multiple fronts. You'll likely find yourself engaging with administration, media, and legislators all while organizing your team and refining your message. The world of advocacy moves fast, and your ability to multitask and rapidly respond to developments will be crucial.
1
Precipitating Incident
  • An event occurs that sparks concern among Jewish students (e.g., antisemitic incident, controversial campus policy)
  • It reflects a wider problem that only activist pressure can solve
2
Initial Response (Days 1-3)
  • Students begin documenting incidents and gathering evidence
  • Informal discussions among affected students and allies begin
3
Organization Phase (Days 1-3)
  • Students form an advocacy group or coalition
  • Initial strategy meetings are held
  • Roles are assigned within the group
4
Preparation of Initial Report (Days 3-4)
  • Students compile evidence and testimonies
  • A comprehensive report is drafted, including incident details and policy recommendations
5
First Engagement with Administration (Day 4-6)
  • Request for meeting with key university officials is made
  • Students prepare presentation and talking points
  • Meeting is held to present concerns and recommendations
6
Media Outreach (Days 4-6)
  • Press release is prepared and distributed to campus and local media directly after the engagement with administration
  • Students conduct initial media interviews
7
Broadening the Campaign (Days 4-6)
  • Outreach to potential allies (other student groups, faculty members) begins
  • Social media campaign or petitions are launched
8
Legislative Engagement (Days 4-10)
  • Students identify and contact sympathetic legislators
  • Meetings with legislators or their staff are held
  • Legislators are encouraged to apply pressure on the university
9
Follow-up Administrative Engagement (Depends)
  • Second meeting with university officials to discuss progress and reiterate demands
  • Students adjust strategy based on university's response
10
Escalation (if necessary) (Days 20-30)
  • If demands are not met, students may organize peaceful demonstrations or other visibility events
  • Additional media outreach and public awareness campaigns are conducted
11
Continued Pressure and Negotiation (Days 30-60)
  • Regular check-ins with administration to track progress
  • Ongoing media presence and public awareness efforts
  • Continuous evidence gathering and documentation of any new incidents
  • Keeping legislators informed of efforts and progress
12
Resolution and Policy Implementation (Days 100+)
  • University announces policy changes or other resolutions
  • Students monitor implementation of agreed-upon changes
13
Long-term Follow-up (Ongoing)
  • Regular meetings with administration to ensure compliance with agreements
  • Continued documentation of campus climate
  • Preparation for potential future advocacy needs
1. Laying the Groundwork
Building Your Advocacy Team
In an ideal world, you'd have the luxury of carefully selecting each member of your advocacy team. However, reality often unfolds differently. You might find yourself thrust into action with whoever is available and willing to stand up. The Renew the Wisconsin Idea campaign didn't have the opportunity to handpick its team, yet we still achieved significant results. Remember, this playbook and its tools are designed to help you succeed regardless of your team's initial skill level or composition.
That said, if you do have the chance to build or expand your team, here are some key considerations:
Diversity of Skills and Perspectives:
  • Aim for a mix of personalities and skill sets. You'll benefit from having:
  • Strong, assertive voices who can lead discussions and negotiations
  • Empathetic individuals who can share personal stories effectively
  • Detail-oriented members for research and documentation
  • Journalism or communications students who can liaise with the press
  • Tech-savvy individuals to manage social media and digital outreach
Key Roles to Consider:
Team Leader/Coordinator: Oversees strategy and ensures everyone is aligned
Research Lead: Gathers evidence and prepares reports
Communications Director: Manages messaging and media relations
Outreach Coordinator: Handles stakeholder engagement (administration, legislators, etc.)
Technology/Social Media Manager: Leverages digital tools for the campaign
Remember, these roles can be fluid. In smaller teams, individuals may wear multiple hats. The key is to ensure all essential functions are covered.
Team Dynamics:
  • Foster an environment of open communication and mutual respect
  • Encourage diverse viewpoints while maintaining focus on shared goals
  • Establish clear decision-making processes to avoid internal conflicts
Onboarding and Training:
  • Share this playbook with all team members
  • Hold regular strategy sessions to ensure everyone understands the campaign's objectives and tactics
  • Encourage continuous learning and skill-sharing among team members
Flexibility and Adaptability: As the Renew the Wisconsin Idea campaign demonstrated, you can succeed even if you don't start with an ideal team composition. The key is to remain flexible, leverage each person's strengths, and be willing to learn and adapt as you go.
Remember, passion and commitment can often compensate for initial lack of experience. With the strategies outlined in this playbook, even a group of passionate beginners can become effective advocates for change on campus.
Understanding Your Campus Environment
Before launching your advocacy efforts, it's essential to have a comprehensive understanding of your campus environment. This knowledge will inform your strategy, help you identify potential allies and obstacles, and ensure your efforts are grounded in the realities of your specific institution. Sometimes this is a complicated effort and you don’t have time to do so. Just know that the more you understand your campus environment, the more effective an advocate you will be!

🛠️ Campus Environment Researcher

Visit: Campus Environment Researcher This comprehensive tool conducts in-depth background research on university policies, power structures, and campus climate. It analyzes complex institutional data to provide valuable insights into the current state of your campus environment. The Campus Environment Researcher equips you with crucial knowledge about existing policies, key decision-makers, and potential areas for improvement, enabling you to develop more targeted and effective advocacy strategies. Have a free ChatGPT account and have you created your context statement yet? The context statement is something that gives the AI a background on your initiative, making it easier to work with. If you haven't created one yet, go here: https://chatgpt.com/g/g-xCikrtZq1-context-statement-generator

Researching University Policies and Procedures
  • Familiarize yourself with your university's code of conduct, free speech policies, and protest guidelines.
  • Understand the process for filing complaints or grievances.
  • Research any existing policies related to discrimination, harassment, or antisemitism.
  • Look into the university's disciplinary procedures for student organizations.
Mapping the Power Structure
  • Identify key decision-makers in the administration (e.g., Chancellor, Dean of Students, Vice Chancellor for Student Affairs).
  • Understand the role of the Board of Regents or Board of Trustees.
  • Research the faculty senate or other academic governance bodies.
  • Identify influential student organizations and their leadership.
Analyzing Campus Climate
  • Review recent incidents related to antisemitism or other forms of discrimination on campus.
  • Assess the overall political and social climate on campus.
  • Understand the demographics of the student body, including the Jewish student population.
  • Research any existing initiatives or programs related to diversity, equity, and inclusion.
Identifying Potential Allies and Opposition
  • Look for student groups that might be natural allies (e.g., other minority or religious groups, free speech advocates).
  • Identify faculty members who have spoken out on related issues.
  • Research local community organizations that might support your cause.
  • Be aware of groups or individuals who might oppose your efforts.
Understanding Media Landscape
  • Familiarize yourself with campus media outlets (student newspaper, radio station, etc.).
  • Identify local media that covers campus issues.
  • Research which reporters typically cover higher education or campus issues.
Leveraging Institutional History
  • Research past incidents of antisemitism or related issues on your campus.
  • Understand how the administration has responded to similar situations in the past.
  • Look for precedents that might support your cause.
Assessing Legal Context
  • Understand relevant state laws that might impact campus policies or your advocacy efforts.
  • Be aware of any ongoing legal cases related to campus free speech or discrimination issues.
2. Crafting Your Message and Setting Your Objectives
Create Your Policy Requests
Once you've built your team and understood the campus environment, it's time to understand what you are going to ask of the school administration or other stakeholders. This can be challenging: Use the following method to help you organize your thinking:
1
Define the Problem
  • What's happening on campus that is a problem?
  • Why is it a problem?
  • Who and what is allowing it to become a problem?
2
Discover Points of Leverage
  • What stakeholders are in a position to solve the problem?
  • How could a stakeholder resolve the problem?
  • What pressure or remedial action could a stakeholder take?
3
Develop Your Requests
  • Ensure they are impactful to solving the problem.
  • Make sure that they are actionable by the stakeholder.
  • Do your research and make sure they are legal and not redundant.

🛠️ Policy Request Generator

Visit: Policy Request Generator This powerful tool transforms your advocacy ideas into clear, actionable policy requests. By guiding you through a series of prompts, it helps articulate your demands in a way that's both persuasive and aligned with existing policy frameworks. The Policy Request Generator ensures your voice is heard effectively, increasing the likelihood of your proposals being seriously considered by decision-makers. Have a free ChatGPT account and have you created your context statement yet? The context statement is something that gives the AI a background on your initiative, making it easier to work with. If you haven't created one yet, go here: https://chatgpt.com/g/g-xCikrtZq1-context-statement-generator

Develop Your Core Message
While your requests are important, they'll go nowhere without a powerful message that resonates with your stakeholders. Here are some tips on doing so:
Frame the Problem
  • What story can you tell about the issue that makes it relevant to a broad scope of people?
  • We drew on the time-honored Wisconsin Idea to ask the university to encourage civil dialogue.
Find Resonance
  • Consider how it will resonate with people.
  • What does the media care about? The administration? Your university peers? We decided they cared about non-discrimination and free speech.
Make it Relevant
  • The message should be relevant to the preliminary goals.
  • How can your message be both broad while also furthering your direct goals? We felt that our idealistic strategy was a vehicle for our requests.

🛠️ Message Creator

Visit: Message Framing GPT Message Framing GPT This intelligent AI assistant ensures your campaign's messaging stays on-target and consistent. It helps weave key themes and principles, like the "Wisconsin Idea," throughout your various advocacy materials. By maintaining a coherent narrative across all documents, the Message Framing GPT maximizes the impact and persuasiveness of your campaign's communication strategy. Have a free ChatGPT account and have you created your context statement yet? The context statement is something that gives the AI a background on your initiative, making it easier to work with. If you haven't created one yet, go here: https://chatgpt.com/g/g-xCikrtZq1-context-statement-generator

Segment Your Audience
Your core message is the north star that shines through every part of your campaign. But activism isn't always one-size fits all. When you reach out to different audiences, you need to explain why they — and their own unique beliefs — align with your north star. If done wrong, you risk looking like a chameleon or double-speaker without conviction or common story. If done right, you will adapt your message to reach new and critical audiences.
University Administration
  • Tailor message based on their motivations of creating an inclusive campus environment
Media and Public
  • Tailor message to be newsworthy and something that everyday people care about
State Legislature
  • Democrats: Tailor your message to democratic narratives and priorities
  • Republicans: Tailor your message to republican narratives and priorities
Policy or Action Goals
  • Define preliminary policy goals you are trying to achieve
Coming soon: Audience Segmentation Bot
Remember, the more thoroughly you understand your campus environment, the more effectively you can tailor your advocacy efforts. This knowledge will help you anticipate challenges, identify opportunities, and craft messages that resonate with your specific campus community.
Lesson from Renew the Wisconsin Idea: The campaign's success was partly due to their deep understanding of the university's values and history, particularly the concept of the "Wisconsin Idea." They used this knowledge to frame their arguments in a way that resonated with the university community. Look for similar foundational principles or values at your institution that you can leverage in your advocacy.
The Importance of Research and Documentation
The strength of your advocacy often lies in the quality and credibility of your research and documentation. Nobody wants to listen to someone who talks about feeling unsafe but turns up empty handed when asked for evidence. Arriving at meetings and interviews with with evidence and you can change the course of your advocacy effort.

🛠️ Incident Report Writer (Shorter)

Visit: Incident Report Writer This powerful tool streamlines the process of creating detailed, objective incident reports in a Title VI appendix style. It guides users through documenting events accurately and comprehensively, ensuring all crucial information is captured. The Incident Report Writer helps maintain a consistent, professional standard in your documentation, which is essential for building a strong case in advocacy efforts. Have a free ChatGPT account and have you created your context statement yet? The context statement is something that gives the AI a background on your initiative, making it easier to work with. If you haven't created one yet, go here: https://chatgpt.com/g/g-xCikrtZq1-context-statement-generator

🛠️ Testimonial Copilot (Longer)

Visit: Testimonial Copilot This empathetic AI assistant helps you craft longer-form, authentic, and emotionally resonant testimonials based on your personal experiences or observations. It guides you through the process of capturing the full depth of your story, including the emotional and personal impact of events. The Testimonial Copilot ensures that your voice is heard clearly and powerfully, helping to create compelling narratives that resonate with readers and effectively convey the real-world implications of campus issues. Have a free ChatGPT account and have you created your context statement yet? The context statement is something that gives the AI a background on your initiative, making it easier to work with. If you haven't created one yet, go here: https://chatgpt.com/g/g-xCikrtZq1-context-statement-generator

Gathering Evidence:
  • Establish a system for collecting and organizing incidents of antisemitism, discrimination, or policy violations.
  • Use a standardized form or template for reporting incidents, including: • Date, time, and location • Detailed description of the incident • Names of victims, witnesses, and perpetrators (if known) • Any immediate actions taken • Photos or videos, if available
  • Encourage students to report incidents promptly, emphasizing the importance of detailed, factual accounts.
  • Consider setting up an anonymous reporting system to encourage those who might be hesitant to come forward.
  • If your school has a standardized bias reporting process, be sure to encourage individuals to submit bias incidents through the process in addition.
Analyzing University Policies:
  • Thoroughly review your university's: • Code of Conduct • Non-discrimination policies • Free speech and protest guidelines • Disciplinary procedures
  • Identify any inconsistencies in policy enforcement or gaps in protection for Jewish students.
  • Research peer institutions' policies for comparison and potential improvement suggestions.
Compiling Comprehensive Reports:
  • Organize your findings into clear, well-structured reports.
  • Include: • Executive summary • Detailed incident logs • Analysis of policy violations • Impact on Jewish students and campus climate • Recommendations for action
  • Use data visualization (charts, graphs) to illustrate trends or patterns.
  • Have team members review and fact-check all information before finalizing.
Leveraging External Resources:
  • Consult with legal experts or organizations specializing in campus antisemitism.
  • Utilize resources from national Jewish organizations for data on broader trends.
  • Consider Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) requests for relevant university documents if necessary.
Maintaining Confidentiality and Ethical Standards:
  • Protect the privacy of individuals who report incidents.
  • Ensure all documentation adheres to ethical standards and university privacy policies.
  • Be prepared to redact sensitive information when sharing reports publicly.
Using Documentation Effectively:
  • Present your findings in meetings with administration.
  • Share relevant data with media, always respecting privacy concerns.
  • Use documentation to support policy change proposals.
  • Keep records updated for ongoing advocacy efforts and to track progress over time.
Tools and Technology:
  • Utilize secure, collaborative platforms for storing and organizing data.
  • Consider using data analysis tools to identify patterns or trends in incidents.
  • Implement a version control system to track changes and updates to your documentation.
Remember, the strength of your advocacy often lies in the quality and credibility of your research and documentation. This evidence-based approach can be a powerful tool in effecting change on your campus.
3. Structuring Your Report
Comprehensive Reports: A Powerful Tool for Advocacy
A well-structured report is a potent instrument in advocacy. It can serve as a compelling reason for administrators to grant you a meeting, or if a meeting is already secured, it provides a framework to present your case effectively. The report we created for the Renew the Wisconsin Idea campaign was instrumental in demonstrating the seriousness of our concerns and the thoroughness of our approach.
You can view that report in full below:

PDF file

Chancellor and Students May 6 Renew.pdf

246.6 KB

Key Components of an Effective Report:
  1. Clear and Concise Message: Your report should open with a clear, concise statement of your primary concerns and objectives. This sets the tone for the entire document and immediately communicates the importance of your cause. Example: We began our report with a brief overview of the encampment situation and its impact on Jewish and Israeli students, framing it within the context of the Wisconsin Idea.
  1. Demonstration of Harm: Provide specific examples and evidence of how current policies or situations are causing harm to students. This section should be detailed and well-documented. Example: We included anonymized testimonies from affected students, photos of antisemitic incidents, and data on reported harassment cases.
  1. Specific Policy Solutions: Present clear, actionable policy recommendations. These should be well-researched and feasible within the university's framework. Example: We outlined our 12 policy requests, each accompanied by a brief rationale and potential implementation strategy.
  1. Evidence of Commitment: Demonstrate that your group is committed to seeing this through. This can be shown through the depth of your research, the organization of your report, and your plans for ongoing advocacy. Example: We included a timeline of our activities leading up to the report, as well as our plans for future actions, including media outreach and legislative engagement.
  1. Detailed Supporting Evidence: Include an appendix with additional evidence, research, and resources. This shows the depth of your investigation and provides administrators with further information if needed. Example: Our appendix included full testimonies, relevant university policies, comparative data from other institutions, and legal precedents supporting our requests.
Structuring Your Report:
  1. Executive Summary: A brief overview of the situation, your key concerns, and your primary requests.
  1. Background: Provide context for the current situation and why action is necessary.
  1. Impact Analysis: Detail the harm caused by the current policies or situation, using specific examples and data.
  1. Policy Recommendations: Present your solutions, explaining how each addresses the identified problems.
  1. Implementation Strategies: Offer suggestions on how your recommendations could be put into practice.
  1. Conclusion: Reiterate the importance of action and your commitment to working towards solutions.
  1. Appendices: Include supporting documents, additional evidence, and resources.
Tips for Maximum Impact:
  1. Use clear, professional language throughout the report.
  1. Include visual elements like charts or graphs to illustrate key points.
  1. Ensure the report is well-formatted and easy to navigate.
  1. Have multiple people proofread the document for errors and clarity.
  1. Consider the timing of your report submission for maximum impact.
Remember, your report is often the first impression administrators will have of your group and your cause. A well-structured, professional report demonstrates that you are serious, well-informed, and committed to constructive dialogue. It sets the stage for productive meetings and ongoing engagement with university leadership.
4. Meeting with Administrators
Meeting with Administrators: Maximizing Your Impact
Congratulations on securing a meeting with administrators! This is a crucial step in your advocacy journey. However, the real work begins before you step into that room. Here's how to prepare for and conduct an effective meeting:
Pre-Meeting Preparation:
  1. Ensure all groundwork is complete:
  • Finalize your report and key talking points
  • Gather all necessary evidence and documentation
  • Prepare responses to potential counterarguments
  1. Hold a strategy session:
  • Assign specific roles to team members based on their strengths
  • Practice your presentations and responses to potential questions
  • Agree on your non-negotiables and areas of flexibility
Assigning Roles:
Speakers:
Choose articulate team members who can:
  • Present your case clearly and concisely
  • Share powerful personal narratives that illustrate the impact of the issues
  • Respond to questions with composure and clarity
Legal/Policy Experts:
Include team members who:
  • Are well-versed in university policies and relevant laws
  • Can quickly counter administrative arguments with facts and precedents
Relationship Managers:
Utilize team members who:
  • Have existing positive relationships with administrators
  • Can help maintain a constructive tone throughout the meeting
Note-takers:
Assign discreet members to:
  • Document all key points, promises, and follow-up items
  • Capture any inconsistencies or concerning statements for later review
Silent Observers:
Some team members should:
  • Observe body language and unspoken dynamics
  • Provide written notes or signals to speakers if necessary
During the Meeting:
Stay on Message:
  • Stick to your prepared talking points
  • Continually bring the conversation back to your key requests
  • Don't let administrators derail the conversation with tangential issues
Be Appropriately Adversarial:
  • Maintain a respectful but firm tone
  • Don't be swayed by appearances of collaboration that lack substance
  • Press for specific commitments and timelines
Handle Excuses Effectively:
  • Anticipate common excuses and have prepared responses
  • Use your evidence and personal stories to counter dismissive attitudes
  • Ask for specific explanations when given vague responses
Avoid On-the-Spot Negotiations:
  • The meeting is for presenting your case and gauging administrative response
  • Defer any requests for concessions or compromises for later discussion with your full team
Post-Meeting Actions:
Debrief immediately with your team
  1. Document all outcomes, promises, and areas of concern
  1. Plan your next steps based on the administration's responses
  1. Communicate relevant outcomes to your broader support base
Potential Pitfalls to Avoid:
Disruptive Team Members:
  • Identify and address any team members who may derail your efforts by focusing on personal issues or topics outside your mission
  • If necessary, have a private conversation with these individuals before the meeting to realign their focus or reconsider their participation
Premature Concessions:
  • Resist the urge to negotiate or give concessions during the initial meeting
  • Any adjustments to your requests should be made after careful consideration with your full team
Misreading Administrative Intent:
  • Be aware that expressions of collaboration may be genuine or may be attempts to relieve pressure
  • Judge the administration's intent by their concrete actions and commitments, not just their words
Losing Sight of Long-Term Goals:
  • Remember that this meeting is part of a longer campaign
  • Be prepared to adjust your strategy based on the meeting's outcomes, but don't abandon your core objectives
Remember, the Renew the Wisconsin Idea campaign ultimately needed to adjust some of our requests when we realized they wouldn't be honored. However, this realization allowed us to refocus our efforts on other strategic priorities. Stay flexible in your tactics, but firm in your overall mission.
By following these guidelines, you'll be well-prepared to make the most of your meeting with administrators, advancing your cause while maintaining the integrity of your campaign.
5. Bringing Pressure from the Media and Legislature
Media Strategy
Effectively engaging with the media can significantly amplify your message and increase pressure on university administration. A well-executed media strategy can pressure the administration, help shape public opinion and create a supportive environment for your advocacy efforts. A focus on three core elements will bring you success with the media. Here is how we succeed in our campaign:
Broad Outreach:
We reached out to hundreds of news-desks at once after getting their emails from websites. This scale meant that we had a high chance of hearing back
Compelling Press Releases:
We crafted and refined our press releases by working with students in the school of journalism to make them newsworthy, impactful and true to our advocacy message
Great Media Spokespeople
We recruited top-tier students who were good on camera, weaving our messaging into personal and compelling stories that made headlines
Media Outreach Tools

🛠️ Media Interview Trainer

View: Media Interview Trainer This invaluable tool prepares you to shine in media interviews by generating potential questions, crafting key talking points, and providing tips for effective communication. It helps you anticipate challenging queries and develop concise, impactful responses that align with your campaign's core message. The Media Interview Preparation GPT ensures you enter every interview confident and well-equipped to clearly convey your advocacy goals to any audience. Have a free ChatGPT account and have you created your context statement yet? The context statement is something that gives the AI a background on your initiative, making it easier to work with. If you haven't created one yet, go here: https://chatgpt.com/g/g-xCikrtZq1-context-statement-generator

🛠️ Press Release Writer

View: Press Release Writer This AI assistant is your key to crafting compelling press releases that effectively communicate your campaign's message to media outlets. It guides you through structuring the release, ensuring all crucial elements are included and properly formatted. The Press Release Writer GPT helps highlight key information for maximum impact, increasing the chances of your story being picked up and accurately reported by journalists. Have a free ChatGPT account and have you created your context statement yet? The context statement is something that gives the AI a background on your initiative, making it easier to work with. If you haven't created one yet, go here: https://chatgpt.com/g/g-xCikrtZq1-context-statement-generator

Media list generator (Coming Soon)
Media Strategy generator (Coming Soon)
Example Media Outreach Timeline
1
Your group achieves something like publishing requests
2
Develop a list of media contacts at local and national outlets
3
Craft a standard press release that makes the activist effort newsworthy
4
Receive requests for interviews from reporters
5
Select and train key representatives of your group
6
Conduct the interviews and send follow ups to thank reporters
7
Keep a list of reporters and maintain relationship for future press releases
8
Measure media impact and adjust your strategy
Tips on Your Outreach
1. Developing Your Media List:
  • Create a comprehensive list of relevant media contacts, including: • Campus media (student newspaper, radio, TV) • Local newspapers, radio stations, and TV channels • National Jewish publications • Higher education focused outlets (e.g., Chronicle of Higher Education)
  • Research and identify journalists who have covered similar issues in the past
  • Regularly update your media list with new contacts and remove outdated ones
2. Crafting Press Releases:
  • Write clear, concise press releases that follow standard journalistic format
  • Include a compelling headline, dateline, and lead paragraph summarizing the key points
  • Provide relevant background information and quotes from key stakeholders
  • End with contact information for media inquiries
  • Use a professional tone and avoid inflammatory language
3. Preparing for Interviews:
  • Designate and train specific team members as media spokespersons
  • Develop a set of key messages and talking points for consistency across all interviews
  • Practice answering difficult questions and staying on message
  • Prepare personal stories and concrete examples to illustrate your points
  • Be ready with facts and figures to support your arguments
4. Utilizing Various Media Channels:
  • Traditional Media: Pitch stories to newspapers, TV, and radio stations
  • Social Media: Maintain active, professional accounts on platforms like Twitter, Facebook, and Instagram
  • Op-Eds and Letters to the Editor: Submit well-crafted pieces to relevant publications
  • Campus Media: Engage regularly with student journalists and publications
5. Timing Your Media Outreach:
  • Coordinate media releases with significant events or milestones in your campaign
  • Be prepared to respond quickly to breaking news or incidents on campus
  • Consider the news cycle when planning your outreach efforts
6. Building Relationships with Journalists:
  • Be responsive and reliable when journalists reach out
  • Offer exclusive stories or interviews to build rapport
  • Provide accurate, timely information to establish credibility
Adjusting Your Efforts
Remember, effective media engagement requires consistency, professionalism, and strategic thinking. Your media strategy should align with your overall campaign goals and messaging. Always be prepared for both positive and negative outcomes of increased media attention.
Legislative Advocacy
Engaging with legislators can be a powerful tool in your advocacy efforts. Lawmakers can apply pressure on university administrations, propose or support relevant legislation, and bring wider attention to your cause.

🛠️ Legislative Outreach Writer

Visit: Legislative Outreach Writer This powerful tool revolutionizes your approach to contacting legislators by crafting personalized, impactful messages. It tailors each note to the specific interests and voting history of individual lawmakers, significantly increasing the chances of engagement and support. The Legislative Outreach Writer ensures your advocacy efforts resonate with decision-makers, helping you build crucial relationships and gain traction for your cause in the political arena. Have a free ChatGPT account and have you created your context statement yet? The context statement is something that gives the AI a background on your initiative, making it easier to work with. If you haven't created one yet, go here: https://chatgpt.com/g/g-xCikrtZq1-context-statement-generator

A Note on Lobbying and Partisanship
We live in a polarized age where it feels daunting to come to the legislature with a non-partisan issue. After all, your cause isn't "Republican" or "Democrat" — it's something everyone should care about! During the Renew the Wisconsin Idea campaign, we spoke to a lobbyist who gave us a key insight:
As an advocacy organization, you should work with any elected official who will listen to your concerns and help you achieve your goals. This may mean working with legislators with whom you disagree politically. And because of the kinds of issues that legislators already care about, Jews may find themselves with "strange political bedfellows." The best thing you can do as an advocate is to reach out to both sides with the same core message, while tailoring your outreach to resonate with the things they care about.
Laying the Groundwork
Identifying Key Legislators:
  • Research state representatives and senators whose districts include your campus
  • Identify lawmakers who sit on education committees or have shown interest in higher education issues
  • Look for legislators with a history of supporting Jewish causes or combating antisemitism
  • Consider both majority and minority party members for bipartisan support
Doing a Successful Outreach
  • Prepare a compelling note to the legislators that will highlight your concerns and request action
  • Compile a list of state legislator's contact information, including emails
  • Load this contact information into a customer relationship management system (CRM) like PipeDrive
  • This will allow you to send personalized notes at scale and keep track of your efforts
  • Transfer the note into an email template with a personalized to field like this: "Dear Senator {lastname}"
  • Send the outreach note
Note that there are other strategies for outreach as well:
Phone Banking
Put together a group and script and call legislators
Contact Forms
If the emails are not available, you may have to submit your note via contact forms
Targeted Outreach
You may decide it is easier to discover 15 friendly lawmakers and take a more targeted approach
Building Relationships with Lawmakers:
  • Request in-person meetings or video calls with legislators or their staff
  • Attend town halls or other public events where legislators are present
  • Invite lawmakers to relevant campus events or discussions
Preparing for Legislative Meetings:
  • Develop a concise, compelling presentation of your concerns and requests
  • Prepare a one-page summary document to leave behind after meetings
  • Practice your presentation with your team, anticipating potential questions
  • Bring supporting documentation, including incident reports and policy analyses
Conducting Effective Legislative Meetings:
  • Clearly state the purpose of your meeting and your desired outcomes
  • Share personal stories and concrete examples to illustrate the impact of campus antisemitism
  • Explain how addressing your concerns aligns with the legislator's interests and constituents
  • Be specific about how the legislator can help (e.g., writing letters to university administration, proposing legislation)
  • Follow up after the meeting with a thank-you note and any promised information
Potential Followup Actions
Drafting Legislative Proposals:
  • Research existing laws and regulations related to campus antisemitism and free speech
  • Consult with legal experts or organizations specializing in higher education policy
  • Draft clear, concise language for potential legislation or amendments
  • Consider the broader implications and potential opposition to your proposals
Mobilizing Grassroots Support:
  • Organize letter-writing or call-in campaigns to legislators' offices
  • Use social media to encourage supporters to contact their representatives
  • Create petitions to demonstrate widespread support for your cause
Leveraging Legislative Support:
  • Request letters from supportive legislators to university administration
  • Seek opportunities for legislators to make public statements or press releases about your issues
  • Explore possibilities for legislative hearings or investigations into campus antisemitism
Navigating Potential Challenges:
  • Be prepared for varying levels of receptiveness from different lawmakers
  • Maintain a non-partisan approach, focusing on the issues rather than party politics
  • Be aware of legislative calendars and election cycles when planning your outreach
Staying Informed and Engaged:
  • Monitor relevant legislative activities and committee hearings
  • Subscribe to lawmakers' newsletters and social media accounts
  • Attend relevant legislative sessions or watch online when possible
6. Measuring Outcomes and Adjusting
Measuring Outcomes
At some point, you'll wonder what progress you've made. Advocacy against antisemitism is hard work! Sometimes, you don't get the goals that you seek. It's better if you can set measurements for outcomes to understand whether you've reached your goals or not. This helps you know what's working and what needs to change. By tracking your progress, you can celebrate small wins and figure out where to focus your efforts next.
Here area few tips on measuring outcomes:
1
Develop clear metrics and goals to assess the impact of your advocacy efforts
  • I.e - Quality of administration's response, # of legislative responses, # of policy requests honored
2
Regularly evaluate and analyze the results to identify areas of success and areas that need improvement
  • I.e - Shift policy goals in response to feedback, change outreach strategy if it is not working
3
Use the insights gained to adjust your strategies and tactics accordingly for more effective advocacy in the future.
  • Recognize that advocacy is a fluid and dynamic balance between your goals and what is possible
Matrix Tool to Assess University Response
When our group received a formal response from the university, we used the following spreadsheet to track our progress against our policy requests. On Y axis cells, we put our policy requests. On the X axis cells we put the university's response. By coloring in the cells at the intersection with green (accepted), red (denied) or yellow (ambiguous), we were able to track our progress.
Adjusting
You are going to receive news that administrators aren't interested in certain of your proposals, or that they have different ideas. It's at this crossroads that you will have to learn to adjust or not. This is a critical exercise. Adjusting to unexpected outcomes and divergent ideas from administrators is crucial in effective advocacy against antisemitism. Take the time to understand their perspective and consider how your proposals can be modified or reframed to align with their priorities. Flexibility and adaptability are key in navigating these situations and finding common ground for continued collaboration and progress.
Advocacy Strategy Pivot Tool
After you've received a response from the university, use the following tool to contextualize your requests and consider how you might pivot.
6. Using Technology to Scale Your Efforts
Technology and Innovation
Our campaign leveraged cutting-edge technology and innovative tools to enhance our efficiency, reach, and impact. This approach allowed us to punch above our weight and compete with better-resourced adversaries. Here are the key technologies and innovations we employed:
1
Generative AI for Messaging and Report Writing
  • We extensively used generative AI tools like ChatGPT and Claude to rapidly develop and tailor our messaging for various audiences.
  • In a critical moment, we leveraged AI to write a report in Title VI style under significant time pressure.
  • AI was instrumental in all our writing tasks, from press releases to policy proposals, allowing us to produce high-quality content quickly and consistently.
2
Data Scraping for Contact Lists
  • We utilized AI and data-scraping tools to efficiently compile press lists and legislator email addresses.
  • This approach saved us countless hours of manual copy-and-paste work, allowing us to focus on strategy and outreach.
  • Note: The specific tool used for this task should be documented for future reference.
3
CRM for Targeted Outreach
  • We implemented Pipedrive, a Customer Relationship Management (CRM) system, to manage and execute our outreach efforts.
  • The CRM allowed us to import a spreadsheet containing legislator information (first name, last name, email, and title).
  • We created email templates with personalization tokens, such as "Dear Senator [lastname]" or "Dear Representative [lastname]".
  • This system enabled us to send mass emails that appeared personalized, increasing the likelihood of our messages being read and considered.
4
Email Blast Strategy
  • By using the CRM, we were able to send out customized emails to all legislators in under an hour.
  • The personalization (particularly the correct use of titles and last names) significantly increased the chances of our emails being opened and read.
  • This approach allowed us to reach a large number of decision-makers efficiently, amplifying our voice despite limited resources.
5
Streamlined Workflow
  • The integration of these technologies created a streamlined workflow that allowed our small team to operate with the efficiency of a much larger organization.
  • We could quickly pivot from content creation to outreach, maintaining momentum throughout the campaign.
Lessons Learned:
  • Technology can be a great equalizer in advocacy work, allowing small groups to compete with larger, established organizations.
  • Personalization at scale is possible and highly effective when leveraging the right tools.
  • Investing time in setting up and learning these systems pays off in increased efficiency and reach.
  • Staying up-to-date with the latest technological tools can provide a significant advantage in fast-moving advocacy campaigns.
Future Recommendations:
  • Maintain a living document of useful tech tools and their applications for quick reference in future campaigns.
  • Regularly explore new technologies that could further enhance advocacy efforts.
  • Train team members on these tools to ensure widespread adoption and utilization.
7. Empowering Jewish Student and Community Advocates
As we conclude this playbook, it's crucial to reflect on its purpose: empowering Jewish students to effectively combat antisemitism and create a safer campus environment. The strategies, tools, and insights shared here are not just theoretical concepts—they are battle-tested approaches that have yielded real results in addressing the unique challenges faced by Jewish students.
Remember these core lessons from our Renew the Wisconsin Idea campaign:
  1. Thorough preparation is your foundation. Understanding your campus environment, documenting antisemitic incidents, and crafting a compelling message are essential to your advocacy's success.
  1. Flexibility in the face of adversity is crucial. While you should have clear goals, be prepared to adjust your approach when faced with resistance or unexpected challenges.
  1. Technology can level the playing field. By leveraging AI, CRM systems, and other digital tools, you can amplify your voice and efficiency, allowing you to compete with better-resourced opposition.
  1. Persistence is key in addressing deep-seated issues. Combating antisemitism is often a long-term effort. Stay committed, celebrate small victories, and keep pushing forward.
  1. Your unique perspective as a Jewish student matters. Your lived experiences and insights are powerful tools for educating others and driving change in university policies and campus climate.
The Power of Community and Self-Care
As you embark on your advocacy journey, remember that you're part of a larger community. Jewish people across the country are united in the fight against antisemitism. Reach out to other Jewish student groups and national organizations. Share your experiences and learn from each other's successes and challenges.
Importantly, prioritize self-care and community support. Confronting antisemitism can be emotionally draining — I know it was for me. Being an advocate can sometimes feel like the weight of the community is resting on your shoulders. Make time for Jewish togetherness — whether that is through religious practice or like-community — and find strength in others.
Your efforts today are creating a better tomorrow for Jewish students and fostering a campus environment that truly embraces diversity and inclusion. By standing up against antisemitism, you're upholding the values of respect and equal treatment that should be at the core of higher education.
Your Advocacy Journey Begins
As you close this playbook and begin your advocacy work, carry with you the knowledge, skills, and determination you've gained. Your actions have the power to create meaningful change, challenge antisemitic narratives, and build a campus community where Jewish students can thrive without fear or discrimination. You'll do so by taking the high road and taking advocacy and influence seriously. While your adversaries yell and vandalize, you are collecting your allies.
Remember, while the path may be challenging, it is deeply meaningful. Your voice, your experiences, and your commitment are powerful forces in the fight against antisemitism. Go forth with confidence, knowing that you have the tools and the strength to make a real difference.
The future of Jewish life on your campus is in your hands. Make it a future of pride, safety, and open celebration of Jewish identity.
Thank you,
Ben Newman